Assessing instrumental music can be an especially challenging endeavor for some reason. Seems more difficult to wrap our heads around this stuff, perhaps because we’ve been trained to rely on labels and descriptions and an overt “this is what it’s about”-ness that is often provided by the lyric as well as the vocal performance of those lyrics.
One might try to argue that it’s “easier” to write/record great instrumental records, because you don’t have to finish it. You don’t need to write words or find a good singer. But the flip side (there’s always a flip side) is the challenge of holding a listener’s attention with just instrumentals. And nothing here sounds “unfinished” by any means. I’m a fan of the kinds of albums flexible enough for a roadtrip or for sitting around a fire, indoors or out. And many instrumental albums fit that bill, the kind of records that are welcome company on both Saturday nights and Sunday mornings. We’ve not included jazz or classical for the purposes of this list, only because they are obviously major genres of their own and their most famous works would easily fill several Top 10’s before we got to any of the other “instrumental albums” we’ll be listing here. And, with apologies to Jeff Beck and King Crimson and Dick Dale, this is not a comprehensive list of the most important or influential instrumental recordings, simply my favorites.
Peter Gabriel – Passion: Music from The Last Temptation of Christ
One impetus for making this list was Peter Gabriel’s Passion, the music he did for Martin Scorsese’s film The Last Temptation of Christ. At the time (and since), Gabriel was known as the man who made hits with his “Sledgehammer,” the former Genesis singer who’d given us quirky modern pop gems like “Games Without Frontiers” and “Shock the Monkey.” By the time John Cusak lifted that boom box above his head and blasted Gabriel’s “In Your Eyes” in the movie Say Anything, it was obvious that Peter Gabriel was capable of being a goose-bump giver. [And yes, Cusak’s character lifted a boom box over his head with intentions of impressing and winning over a girl.]
Enter Scorsese and his bold new film project based on the book by Nikos Kazantzakis. The subject matter and hype around the movie passed for controversial at the time (portraying Christ as a human man I guess? Is that what the fuss was?), but the film itself turned out to be a beauty, for those of us not offended. And the ebbs and flows of the film are not only captured and accentuated by Gabriel’s rustic, tribal score, Passion can stand on it’s own as a musical work, it’s pacing and dynamics worthy of repeated listenings whether you’ve ever seen the film or not. Interestingly enough, Passion managed to not only further popularize world music, it also landed a Best New Age Album Grammy award.
Sly & Robbie – Dub Revolutionaries: Sly & Robbie Meet the Mad Professor
Once upon a time, the words “sick” and “ridiculous” came to be synonymous with what we used to know and refer to as “awesome” or “killer.” I’m not sure when or where this happened, but I’m pretty sure this album was playing in the background. This is the kinda shit that’ll make you black out on a long late-night road trip, and I mean that in the best possible way. If you want throbbing reggae beats with dubbed out production that dazzles when it’s not hypnotizing, you need to get with this.
Explosions in the Sky – Take Care, Take Care, Take Care
This was the other album that got me thinking about instrumental music and pushed me to try formulating this list. Interestingly enough, though these instrumental rockers have been around for a few years and albums, this new one is the only one I’ve heard. I’ll be sure to check out their other stuff, but this six song set rocks with a dynamic pacing that never bores.
Bill Laswell/Bob Marley – Dreams of Freedom: Ambient Translations of Bob Marley in Dub
Legendary producer Bill Laswell had access to all the original tracks from Bob Marley’s catalog, so when a bass line drops you know it’s legit. Working that rarefied air between dub remixes and ambient electronica, with the potentially blasphemous Marley canon has his canvas (and paint?) Laswell manages a mellow groove that never taints the original. It’s the kinda thing that looks like it can only fail on the surface, but somehow it works with stunning results. This album will make you float.
Vernon Reid – Mistaken Identity
Guitar virtuoso from Living Colour breaks off to make an ambitious record blending furious guitar-rock styling with some hip-hop flavor. A few songs feature verses of rap vocal, but still a mostly instrumental affair. Worth it for Reid’s shredding alone.
DJ Shadow – Endtroducing
Eerie melodies work beneath the surface of this hip-hop collage that managed to work the fundamentals of many musical styles into an album that helped launch the art of DJ’ing into a respectable musical art form beyond the boundaries of rap.
Sonic Youth – Simon Werner A Disparu
Legendary NYC noise rockers make an instrumental soundtrack. Click here to read our original review.
Santana – Caravanserai
OK, so only 7 out of the 10 tracks on this are instrumental, but we’ll include it here anyway. After storied success with their first few albums, 1972’s Caravnserai signaled a shift toward more jazz-rock musicianship and less hit singles for Santana, but this is still a giant gem to be treasured.
From the Bums Logic staff peanut gallery:
Lennsakata: To make up for the unlikelihood of a hip hop album on that list, I’d argue for J Dilla’s Donuts. [Also, I think this may be for another list, but I think DJ mixtapes are technically “instrumentals” because it’s about the instrumentality of the turntables, not the lyrical content. So, under those parameters, I would include “Five Deadly Venoms of Brooklyn.” Again, though, I think that’s for another top ten.]
Jaded Bitterman: Yes, that Sly & Robbie Dub Revolutionaries is just dope in every sense of the word. I’d also add Frank Zappa’s Hot Rats as well as this jazzy acid-house comp The Future Sounds of Jazz Volume 5.
Jr.Worthy: While it is not totally instrumental, I really like the soundtrack to Ocean’s 13. David Holmes has some really great tracks plus a few other artists that make the entire album a strong collection.
Bear: As someone who still listens to Reid’s Mistaken Identity, I would not call that an instrumental record. There is way too much vocal work. From English rhymes, Japanese rhymes, dancehall to Larry Fishburne. It’s more of a complete album. But if you consider that instrumental, then I would put Low by David Bowie the list. If you want to stare out your window and watch the rain, put on side two.
And what about the soundtrack to Star Wars? Williams wrote fantastic music for that flick.
I love instrumental music. I play guitar and I primarily listen to guitar-oriented music. Speaking in terms of a guitarist, writing a great instrumental track versus a great track with lyrics are very different. See, most rock is mediocre. Most rock guitarists simply play power chords when the singer is doing his thing and maybe have a cool solo or a nice lick. But to be creative and actually write a good rhythm riff? That’s not as easy as people would think. That said, writing a good instrumental track, in my opinion, is still more difficult and relies on more natural talent and creativity. Some of the most famous guitarists (a la Joe Satriani) are ridiculously creative and different. Some aren’t. But to me, there’s nothing better than a well-executed instrumental track.
I’m also a philosophy guy, so I can explain why (whether you like it or not!). See, language is a very impersonal form of communication. We all have our personal thoughts, but language needs to be impersonal so that there is a standard, which allows us to understand one another. But the limitations and impersonality of language still leave something to be desired. So even when lyrics are beautiful, a beautiful and emotive instrumental song will leave you feeling more.
And with that, I’ll tell you my favorite instrumental albums. In no particular order.
Andy James- In the Wake of Chaos (song you MUST check out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Chfa7opyrow)
Andy James- Andy James
Marco Sfogli- There’s Hope (song you MUST check out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUojLC30ejI) And check out Seven. And the title track of the album.
John Petrucci- Suspended Animation (song you MUST check out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8GfFqCy58U)
Joe Satriani- Super Colossal (song you MUST check out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6fqVFGtm5S0)
Joe Satriani- Is There Love in Space (song you must check out: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RYHd1DGUyy0)
I’m a rock->metal guy.
Love that Santana album!
my insane friend (and i do mean the literal definition) Heru Avenger…John Capociama
Danzig’s Black Aria
[…] “Desert Island Classic” list of the Top 10 Best Rock Albums and no one really cares what my favorite instrumental albums or Top 10 Live Albums are, but I wrote those lists anyway (and can I interest you in my Top […]